EVENS 2.What is a “master narrative,” as Alexander describes it in her paraphrase of Lyotard? What, according to Alexander, are some problems with these narratives? Revisit your own literacy narrative from English 122. Do you find her point about them
EVENS
2.What is a “master narrative,” as Alexander describes it in her paraphrase of Lyotard? What, according to Alexander, are some problems with these narratives? Revisit your own literacy narrative from English 122. Do you find her point about them convincing? Why or why not? Support your response with textual evidence from Alexander and reflection on your narrative. (15 minutes) “Master” is more common because more people can relate to it. Little narrative is more specific. Little narrative challeneges are in almost every literacy narrative. She believes Literacy Narratives are more important because “I couldn’t just let my mind go free. I had to write about what I was assigned. i couldn’t just let my mind go free. The required course materials are what tore my love for writing”.
4.Table 1 identifies eight distinct cultural narratives of literacy (Alexander 615), and the bulk of our reading selection is dedicated to discussion of these types. Pick any two types of “little narratives” that interest you, explain each of the little narratives and Alexander’s view on the type, and discuss your reasons for being interested in each type. (Note: “Success” is not a little narrative, so it is off limits for this question!) Be sure to quote from Alexander. (15 minutes)I chose Child Prodigy which is someone who excels in literacy at a young age. I like the term prodigy because it makes you stand out from the rest of the pack. Alexander describes Child Prodigy as “when students portrayed themselves as child prodigies, they conceived of themselves and their literacy abilities as exceptional, highlighting moment when their skills were put on display to amaze and astonish their audience.” The other term I chose was hero which is when you have a ton of success and establishes themselves as a hero in a literacy story. I thought hero was interesting because its usually the main focus in a story. Alexander quotes “it contextualizes theses claims within an individual account, as we see in Lauren’s account of how she faces and overcomes challenges”.
6.Select at least one of the cultural narrative types identified by Alexander (614-22) and explore the ways that Alexander’s discussion of that type connects to any two of the following concepts from Gee: filtering, transfer, apprenticeship, nondominant secondary discourse. You might consider how Gee’s concepts help to explain Alexander, how they complicate Alexander, or both. Be sure to quote Alexander and Gee in your response. (20 minutes) Child prodigy is similar to Brandts statement. Alexander believes “when students portrayed themselves as child prodigies, they conceived of themselves and their literacy abilities as exceptional, highlighting moment when their skills were put on display to amaze and astonish their audience.” In Brandts passage, the quote used is “… a range of human relationships and ideological pressure that turn up at the scenes of literacy learning”. These two have a lot in common. You can’t be a prodigy without assistance from a sponsor.
“collreadwrit2e”